Question: Is The Live Action Dumbo Good?

Why was Dumbo so bad?

The story is also not a joyful one.

Dumbo is bullied by humans for his big ears and the circus animals are treated poorly.

The movie deals with animal abuse, war, and death.

Some of the material may be too heavy for children..

How did Dumbo die?

The tragic true story of the celebrity elephant that inspired ‘Dumbo’: An exploited, alcoholic circus act sedated from his nightly tantrums by being fed gallons of booze – before he was hit and killed by a train. At around 8.15pm on September 15, 1885, Jumbo, the celebrity elephant in P.T.

Why did Dumbo get bad reviews?

Dumbo currently has a score of 50% on Rotten Tomatoes, and the general feeling across both the positive and negative reviews is one of apathy, with critics saying that the movie doesn’t have enough of Burton’s usual flair or the original film’s magic.

Is the new Dumbo sad?

They’re sad, but aware of the greater good of Dumbo leaving their lives. “The kids understand that sometimes you have to say goodbye to things that you love,” Farrell says. … In the new “Dumbo,” the final shots show the baby elephant and his mother arriving at an idyllic African watering hole, joyfully back in the wild.

Is the original Dumbo sad?

Dumbo is about as light of a kid’s movie as you can get, though, it can be really sad in places. However, no one ever died in the original, which you can’t say about the remake. Early on in the film, there’s a mean circus worker who hates Holt because of… reasons, and he especially seems to hate the elephants.

Is Dumbo a dark movie?

‘Dumbo’ Is Disney’s Darkest Children’s Movie in Years.

What age is Dumbo 2019 suitable for?

7Age Appropriate For: 7+. This live-action version of the animated Disney original again focuses on a young elephant who is mocked for his overly large ears; there is some bullying throughout, and one particularly cruel elephant handler threatens to use violence against the animals.

What is Dumbo controversy?

Controversy. The film has been criticized by some for its handling of race. … Film scholar Richard Schickel, in his 1968 book The Disney Version, argued that the group of crows in the film were African American stereotypes.

Is Dumbo a real life story?

It is believed that the story of Dumbo is loosely based on the real life elephant Jumbo, a male African Bush elephant born in Sudan in 1860. After his mother was killed by poachers he was captured and sold to Lorenzo Casanova, an Italian animal dealer and explorer. … Jumbo and his trainer Matthew Scott, 1885.

Is Dumbo a bad word?

adjective. stupid or foolish: What a dumbo idea!

Is the live action Dumbo sad?

Movie Review: Tim Burton’s live-action ‘Dumbo’ too sad for intended audience. Tim Burton directs the live-action remake of “Dumbo,” but children might find the film relentlessly sad and scary.

Is Dumbo worth watching?

I’m not sure, but the strangely timed critique alone makes the movie worth watching. On the surface, Dumbo is a perfectly adequate family film about a circus, a flying elephant, and the kids who believe in him. But the subtext is startlingly subversive.

Does Dumbo die?

At the end of the animated movie, Dumbo stays in the circus and gets his mom bailed out of elephant jail and into a private train cart. But in the end of the newer movie, Dumbo and Mrs. Jumbo are released back into the wild and free from the circus tent flaps.

What did Dumbo drink?

“Pink Elephants on Parade” is a song and scene from the 1941 Disney animated feature film Dumbo in which Dumbo and Timothy Q. Mouse, having accidentally become intoxicated (through drinking water spiked with champagne), see pink elephants sing, dance, and play marching band instruments during an hallucination sequence.

Why is Dumbo a 15?

The BBFC insight cites mild threat and brief violence as the reason behind its PG rating. They write: “There is a mild threat when two children who are chased by a circus guard get stuck in a tent which is on fire. “There is brief violence when a man punches another man in the face, resulting in a bloodied lip.